Once again, I am going to be giving away all sorts of spoilers in this review. Reader discretion is advised.
AMAZING SPIDER-MAN #586
Writer: Marc Guggenheim
Penciler: Barry Kitson
Inker: Karl Kesel
Story Title: “Daddy’s Little Girl: Character Assassination Interlude”
Plot
The origin of Menace is revealed.
The Commentary
Before I get into this review I wanted to discuss something I found rather…I don’t know…amusing? Would that be the right word? That doesn’t sound right. Interesting. Yeah. That’s the word. I found something rather interesting about the cover to this installment of Amazing Spider-Man.
I picked this issue up from the comic store last week and looked at it a few moments before handing it to the guy behind the register and paying for it. All the way home something was nagging me about the image on the cover. There was nothing wrong with it. If you are going to have an issue that reveals the true origin of a character than filling the cover with their face is the right way to go. Still and all I was unsettled. It hit me when I got home.
I had seen this cover before.
I didn’t know where at first and I wasn’t about to start digging through my collection because that takes a few days prep work, a couple of union guys and a forklift. I went about my night doing this or that when it occurred to me where I had seen that cover before.
Look at the cover to this issue of Amazing Spider-Man, which should still be visible depending on how big your monitor is.
Now look at the cover to your right.
Interesting, eh?
Now I am not accusing anyone of swiping because that’s just silly. John Romita Jr. is a fantastic artist and would not have to swipe the composition of another artist’s cover, in this case Jeff Purves, for ideas.
Still, I find the whole thing rather interesting, as that is the word we settled on to use.
And now…the review.
I have mixed feelings about this issue. I really do. I enjoyed it to a large extent (which apparently is something of a crime on par with larceny or grand theft auto around here) and thought that it had a compelling explanation for how Lily became Menace, but the fact that it took up an entire issue was unnecessary. I can see where they might want to separate this from the story arc because there was a change of artist, in this case the very talented, liked his work since he drew Adventures of Superman Barry Kitson. Maybe they want to keep the mystique that JRJR drew the whole darn thing. I don’t know. I am not privy to that information.
No matter the explanation it bugs me that they took an entire issue to give us information that could have been revealed in half that time. At the end of the last issue Menace stood revealed as Lily, the Spider Tracer killer(s) stood revealed as well and Peter was taken into custody. All three of these are extremely important plot points and had my attention. I read this week’s issue and all I get is Lily with a few shots of Spider-Man being dragged into the precinct with his mask on because I know if I was the arresting officer the first thing I would be concerned about is the privacy of a wanted criminal accused of all sorts of bad things.
Maybe that’s just me.
Instead of furthering all of the plot threads we focus on Lily and find out why she became Menace. It was a fairly standard villain origin especially in this day and age; Daddy didn’t love me enough so when I get super powers I become a villain. It was told in an entertaining way and I felt something for the character and they even explained “the kiss” but at the end of the day the story felt padded. It’s like they were stalling for time. Guggenheim wrote an effective issue and I kind of dug how bat s#$% insane Lily is but I can’t really get behind this issue after taking in the product as a whole.
The Final Analysis
I have to wonder how the trade of this is going to look now. If the point of calling this issue an Interlude is to not mess up JRJR’s run on the story then where do you put it in the hardcover which will be followed by the softcover which will be followed by Marvel packaging the first three parts in one comic and selling it for five bucks? Do you put it at the end or do you have it as an interlude. Time will tell on that one. For now I’m left a conflicted reader. I loved the art and I liked the story I just don’t like the idea of an Interlude in the middle of a pretty big story line. I was entertained but annoyed. I’ll have a better handle on the whole thing when Character Assassination is over and I can read it all in one sitting. For now though I am not the happiest of readers.
3 out of 5 webheads.
Apple Podcasts
Google Podcasts
Spotify
Pandora
Amazon Music
iHeartRadio
Podbean
Amazon Alexa
Player.fm
Listen Notes
Stitcher
it would seem that spidey is depowerd it seems he lost his enhaced powers from averngers disassembled and te other. but hey if ultimate spidey can get shot why cant 616 spidey?
I agree with SpiderTracer. cool.
I agree that devoting an entire issue to the menace origin reveal would have bugged me if this was still a once-a-month title, but I am actually enjoying the “interlude” and going back to re-read the past several issues, knowing that another installment is coming real soon. Back in my day, many moons ago, I really enjoyed the re-reading and rehashing my friends and I did in anticipation of the next issue. With the 3/month format and the reality of being an adult I don’t seem to have time to rehash as much as I would like to.
GOOD REVIEW MB. you’ve done a great job reviewing the title in your tenure.
2nd this issue was a couple of things for me. as a musician i know that interludes are used to break up the pace and slow things down while still giving you music. thats what this issue did exactly it slowed down the pace of the story but still gave us a story. while the overall story was good and i i have to concur with the masses on this one it shouldnt have taken a full 22 pages and like 18 of them were the psycotic rantings of a blonde mariah carey gone goblin. i actually did enjoying seeing how demented lily is and seein her punk harry was something to behold. lily has effectively handed 2 goblins their asses. harry got off easy remember what she did to norman in new ways to die. but lily’s spurned determination so much harry’s own makes for good animosity between the two lovers. lily’s seem to also suffer from bipolarism telling harry no ealier in the story to the wedding proposal then yes near the end. but looking at the last page of the book i cant wait to see harry and lily’s apprent throw down. SPOILER SPOILER SPOILER ALERT ALERT ALERT (not in the next issue)
I still enjoyed this issue,0 it didn’t lie, it was what it said it was it was an interlude.the art while not the Romita jr art i was expecting was still good. im still enjoying the arc. as for the trade think that the break in the story is kind of necesary becuz in 585 we’re left with harry’s proposal and in this issue we get a resolution to that and we see what harry will do that will come up in 587 yes it will be a huge break in the art style in a trade but if removed and placed at the end of the actual arc there will qquestions left unanswerd and when thet come itll be a WTF moment kind of thing.
No one wants to read about a “god.” Why do you think they have so much trouble making the Sentry work? And I actually LIKE the guy.
Chris is so right when he says about Spidey still being masked and taken in. The first thing the boys in blue would have done is whip that bad boy off Parker’s face. But anyhoo, this issue was lame. I have to admit that I only picked it up for the cover, and once I saw Kitson’s artwork, thought I’d give it a try. As a villain origin, it’s just too formulaic I’m afraid.
But onto something else that’s bothering me since the Spider-Man “reboot.” Is it just me, or is Spidey actually weaker in power. The Spidey I grew up with was super strong and all but untouchable. He could dodge a hail of bullets without even thinking about it. But now…. Spidey’s seems so second rate. Just like his comic, I’m sad to say. Could someone get Roger Stern back, or even David Michelinie. Combine those guys with Romita Jr, and that is one comic I’d buy religiously.
Psycho girlfriend of Harry, huh? How does he pick ’em?
And I liked Future Imperfect…
I agree that the story told in the interlude should have just been part of the ongoing story. There was no real need for an interlude.
Jeff Purves, wasn’t a fan but loved that Vegas Hulk storyline.
CrazyChris is right.
Word up, Crazy Chris.
I liked it. I can see why it was called an “interlude”. It felt like it.
That Hulk makes a better looking chick than Menace.